PREVIOUS HOUR

VP/SC/5.00/3Q

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ (CONTD): And, some of the members might have been even Members of Parliament. So, if the competence of this House, the responsibility of this House is to pass a law exempting certain members of holders of office, it is purely within the domain of this article of this Constitution. Sir, I am reminded that earlier also when I wanted to provide the disqualification on account of defection, I had to amend this, and the Tenth Schedule was inserted. I was the Minister even then. So, if there is a desire of the House, this Government welcomes it that let there be unanimity of the House because this will entail a Constitutional amendment, not a simple Parliamentary law. And if at one point of time we all feel that it is a very difficult subject, and a definition is required, well, you will all agree a definition will have to be inserted in the Constitution like we have inserted the Tenth Schedule. But, what are your utterances outside? I read all responsible leaders saying, "we will not allow tinkering of the main scheme of the Constitution." Is that not the stand of the BJP? That is your stand that we will not allow tinkering with the basic scheme. That was what was done when Mr. L.K. Advani was a Minister in Morarji Desai's Government that the 42nd Amendment was reversed in 44th amendment. Even now, on this issue, you can all appreciate, that no definition can be coined without any Constitutional amendment. I am saying, if there is any other way, it is only to amend article 102 as was done in the 42nd amendment.

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 持指曋 曋, 泣粗 抵泣 埴持 泣 埴泣 综 喼 埴烛欬邫婵之 喆蛛淈粗霗 粗熤 埴赘鼖

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼坳 喼淈局洲诌 曋  埴泣 祁鼌

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 粗 仓熤 更泣 奇狱..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 粗 喼坳 谆謰 泣 埴泣 更泣 奇狱, 喼 弥阕媴..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 喼 仓邥株 坳 谆謰 埴泣 更脐 骑 喼罡 粗 仓邥株 埴 熤更柄 弥 仓株恢 更泣 奇狱, 啹之诌 喼旮 弥 泣 仓株恢 更泣 奇狱 曋弥局疅 孛制 曋 抵泣钟 仓顨挈 骑鼌 限植 粗丬謺轴 曋  仓舟抵 嚸 粗悃挈 更 埉齐 嬠 苤熤 谆周种 喼罡 埫 苤熤 埴 曋局植 谆肿苤熤 粗 埉泣蛛 驻种 讜置执蛛 泣粗 坳只 抵泣 埴泣 综 102 埴 酌赘鼨 埴株 淈值只抵鏅 粗熤 埴赘鼖 抵泣 仓譄 泣粗 喼曋 持 埴泣 更脐 骑鼌 综诌 持 redefinition 粗 嗇指 局泣 酌赘鼨 淈值只抵鏅 泣株熤 祁 熤株 泣粗 埫舟犏 拙指戡诌 V陞 泣粗 泣 埴泣 综 埴烛欬邫婵之只 喆蛛淈粗霗 粗熤 恢謬媴 曋蠲种 喒 曋  仓株恢熤 沏鼖 埴泣, 粗锂株 弥援只诌 喼坳 弥用证抵 埴值衷 粗印诌 埴株 持, 抵泣钟 仓顨挈 骑, 嚠舟 持, 嚠置株 仓浲挈, 庄窒抵赣鼤之 置 粗阌恐 曋 埴株 持 喼罡 嚸舟犏 仓证 限植 粗丬謺轴 曋 弥 持 柄株 更 仓譄 埴更坳 埴泣 综 弥更, 泣粗指挈 抵泣钟 弥粗葜 負譄之 抵泣 仓 祁, 曋株 喼 啹之株 脵挈欬粗霗 喼虮 喼虿曋陮櫵 嬰淈 更邥痔用 粗 埴泣 综 尩种胱埴 嬠 戈种 瞍 泣株 葜抵 祁 喼罡 嬠 ambiguity 坳 埴指, definition 埴 ambiguity 坳 埴指 抵 葜恢谉值种 沏鼑 骑, 恐值证 弥持 恢蛛 弥 沏鼑 骑 嚸肿恢 仓昶鼰指 抵泣 泣株葜 综 局 欬謬粗 塾鷽戤 埴更 株, 恢曜埴 喼葜 坳 谆謰 嚸舟 恢曜曋讬种嚂痔 粗熤 埴更株 抵泣 仓昶鼰指 泣株葜 综 喼 抵泣 埴泣 株 综 讜譄之株 恢株葜 骑, 曋泣钟 曋泣钟 弥, 局 弥仓 啹之株-啹之株 蛛 弥 嚸熤弑 り る 喼罡 喼葜 埴株囋 嫶织诌, 嫶謰恢 嚸舟犏 夲更  喼 熤株 曋熤 埴 弥粗V援 喼埴株 状只 曋謰葜, 愀 葜恢谉值种 塾鷽戤 泣株 曋謰虞诌 曋株 仓譄蛛 喼 埴泣 综 埴株囋 株仓指 撝惝种局  泣株 曋謰, 恢株葜 讻謱局只诌柄謬  泣株 曋謰, 埉 弥仓埴 持 that would be taken care of, 喼罡 嚸舟犏 仓证 喼葜 坳 谆謰 曋熤 埴株 抵泣 恢葜贻种 综 喼 综诌 撝邥痔 埴株 恢曜曋讬种嚂痔 泣 综种 抵泣 粗锂株 弥援只诌 埴泣謪 抵泣钟 弥愀挈恐 撝诸更 曋 仓顨挈 骑, 局 弥瞩诌 骑鼌

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 粗锂株 喼埴 仓譄 弥惝 恢邊 喼 仓钭汓媴

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 曋, 抵泣 泣粗指 脵稂淈 祁鼌

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : り苤 弥懵执种 曋, 抵泣 株-熤更柄 仓譄 泣 撝恢熤邊 ..(镜志脂种).. 弥阕, 粗 喼埴株 仓熤 更泣 奇狱 喼埴株 粗锂株 柄株 综种 综 喼 仓熤謬 综 喼坳 埴诸 弥 嫶织诌 媽曋檀瘷 泣株 骑? 喼 埴泣 综 喼淈局洲诌 曋 曋局植 る株 尩种 喼 粗泗株 抵泣 泣 埴泣?

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 汓咣 仓譄 祁鼌

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼坳 弥仓 嫶织诌 粗旮挈 置 喼 综 粗旮 执 媽曋檀瘷 埴赘鼖 喼埴 謾 ..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 喕州-喕州 尩种 仓譄..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 埴株囋 隉种 熤株 嬯弥 泣株 曋株 仓熤 り 综 喼 尩种 撝制鼰株 骑鼌..(镜志脂种).. 弥阕, 喼曋 持 喼坳 撝弑 拙泣 埴 执 嚸执蛛 喼抵 尩种胱埴 抵泣 埴泣 葜抵 祁 喼罡 喼 嚸舟 拙指戡 埴更 更泣 骑鼌..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 喼 埴泣..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 弥阕, 喼罡 综鸁之株 喼状值种 坳 粗 执 ゆ狱, 喼坳 讜譄之株 嫶织诌 粗旮挈 置 喼 骑鼌..(镜志脂种).. 喼 垲诌 恢邲恐 埴更 更泣 骑? ..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 弥局只 泣 祁 持指曋 曋, 粗锂株 娓挈 嫯譀 埴 熤更柄 弥 限植 曋 埴株 埴泣謪 ..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼 粗泗株 抵泣 仓熤謬 综 粗锂株 喼弥 柄株 更 仓譄 埴 抵 泣 埴邊

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 更 喼 曋仓 粗泗置株 仓譄 埴 熤株 粗锂株 尩种 埴泣 综..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼 埴泣 综 喼淈局洲诌 曋 曋局植 る株

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 撞只坫謪

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼淈局洲诌 曋  抵泣 埴泣 ..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 曋仓 弥指 粗哓欬葜 坳 仓证 喼淈局洲诌 曋  粗泗株 喿坶鸁 综种 综 曋舟 仓熤 株 熤株 粗锂株 苤悚 限植 曋 弥 仓譄 埴 V邊 ..(镜志脂种)..

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Do you want Advaniji's statement? 弥阕, 喼 喼曋 啴謰祝舟 埴泣 更泣 骑..(镜志脂种)..

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 尩种 仓譄 埴更 更脐 骑 喼?..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 嬠 仓譄 埴赘鼖 喼 茂致欬 抵泣 撝制鼰株 骑 综 粗 撝只诌弥 嫶织诌曋 埴株 讻謱局只诌柄謬..(镜志脂种)..

林 埊置殖种谉 : 喼 撝甑指 埴株 嫑谊 埴赘鼖

林叽譄诌 弥懵执种 镁指曋 : 曋仓 喼 局 欬謬粗 戈鼤痔株坏宙恐 埴 仓譄 埴更 更脐 骑 熤株 妆 埴泣钟 弥 讻謱局只诌柄謬 泣蛛葜? ..(镜志脂种)..

林 埊置殖种谉 : 弥懵执种 曋, 抵泣 尩种 泣株 更泣 祁? ..(镜志脂种)..喼 株蛛 粗 抵泣 弥仓 撝恢 更泣 祁鼌

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼 弥阕媴..(镜志脂种).. 喼坳 隉种喼 坳, 喼坳..(镜志脂种)..

(Followed by PB/3R)

PB-MP/3R/5.05

SHRI ARUN JAITLEY: Sir, I have a small question. What is the intention of the Government -- to violate the Constitution with the consent of all or to bring something which ... ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I don't want this kind of interruption. You spoke for one hour and the type of language, which you always use, *

林 埊置殖种谉 : 嚸舟 现昝诌貨曋 弥雨 桩舟恢 咦曋媴 ....(镜志脂种)... 粗锂株 局泣 桩舟恢 驻种 祁鼌 ....(镜志脂种)....持指曋 曋, 喼 坳只 尰诸赘柄坳之 咦曋媴 ...(镜志脂种)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I should be allowed to have my say. ...(Interruptions)... And, Sir, whatever he has said, it should be examined. ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I have expunged it. What else can I do? ...(Interruptions)... 喼罡 尩种 埴更 祁? ...(镜志脂种)...

燬HRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: What objectionable thing have I said? ...(Interruptions)... What have I said? ...(Interruptions).. What have I said? I can answer one, not all of you. ...(Interruptions)... Can you? 嚠泣蛛 曋株 埴泣, 埫舟 曋局植 り 更泣 奇狱 ....(镜志脂种)...

SHRI ARUN JAITLEY: Are we sitting here to take everybody's consent and then bring a legislation which violates the Constitution? ...(Interruptions)... Or, are we to bring a law ... ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: I have never said I consulted ...(Interruptions)...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

* Expunged as ordered by the Chair.

 

林 埊置殖种谉 : 粗锂株 埴泣 综 粗锂株 媽弥訒 埴更 驻种 祁鼌 I expunged those remarks. 粗锂株 埴泣 综 粗锂株 媽弥訒 埴更 驻种 祁鼌 ....(镜志脂种)...粗锂株 媽弥訒 埴更 驻种 祁鼌 ....(镜志脂种)... I have expunged those remarks. ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: At least, you show this courtesy. ...(Interruptions)...

林 埊置殖种谉 : 啿 喼罡 埫执蛛 粗 尩种 埴更 弥埴熤 奇狱? ...(镜志脂种)... 粗 综诌 埴株 埴泣 弥埴熤 奇狱, 恢曜埴 局 局织置 泣 恢隉株, 熤株 粗 ....(镜志脂种)...诌曋....(镜志脂种)...

SHRI S.S. AHLUWALIA: What is this language? ...(Interruptions)... What type of language is he using? ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: 喥帚局肿恢抵 曋 ....(镜志脂种)...

林 埊置殖种谉 : 粗印诌 曋, 曋株 尰诸赘柄坳之弥 骑, 喼 局泣 り る 喼罡 ....(镜志脂种)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I am again saying that you can look into the record and if there is anything unparliamentary, I will take it back. But I should be allowed to make my reply. ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Please make your submission. Nobody is coming in your way. ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I am only saying that what 42nd Amendment provided was an easier way to deal with this problem. ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: He has taken that back. ...(Interruptions)... 埉泣蛛 埴泣 祁, he himself said that if there is anything unparliamentary, he will take it back. He has said that.

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: I am not standing on some false prestige. ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: He has said, if there is anything unparliamentary, he will take it back. ...(Interruptions)... I have also expunged it, although he has taken it back. ...(Interruptions)... He has withdrawn it. 局 仓株恢 更脐 骑 综 拙证鼪尹烛 埴河种 ....(镜志脂种)...

SHRI YASHWANT SINHA: He has to behave properly in the House. ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: I have submitted to the Chair. I cannot be cowed down. Sir, I am saying that if anything that I have said has hurt any of these Members, I am prepared to apologize. ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI S.S. AHLUWALIA: But why did you use that language? ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mr. Ahluwalia, please allow him to speak. ...(Interruptions).. Please sit down.

SHRI JANARDHANA POOJARY: What language has he used? ...(Interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: You don't want me to reply. ...(Interruptions)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mr. Poojary, please take your seat. ...(Interruptions)... Please sit down. ...(Interruptions)...

林 弥煹志治熤 撝熤憔朱 : 嬯弥 持致种 埴 嚸熤甏种恢 泣株熤 祁鼱 ...(镜志脂种)...

林 埊置殖种谉 : り苤, 株蛛 熤更柄 弥 ...(镜志脂种)... 嗇指 局 葜恢熤 仓株恢胼株, 熤株 局泣 持 媽弥訒 综种 曋謰葜謪 ....(镜志脂种)... That is all over. Please, don't go on repeating it. Mr. Narayanasamy, that is over, why are you getting up? Mr. Law Minister, you just reply to the debate. ...(Interruptions)...

(Followed by 3s/SKC)牋

3S/5.10/SKC-ASC

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I am saying, there is nothing illegal or unethical in this law because the Constitution provides power to the Parliament to legislate, and exercising that power, the Prevention of Disqualification Act, 1959 was enacted. I may draw the attention of this august House to the fact that since then several Offices of Profit were added. It started with the Leader of Opposition. All Leaders of Opposition were exempted under this law. Then came the office of Deputy Chairman of Planning Commission. It was exempted under this very law. Then, the offices of Chief Whip, Deputy Chief Whip, and Parliamentary Secretary were exempted under this very law. Thereafter, all Chairmen of Commissions, such as the National Commission for Minorities constituted under a specific section, the National Commission for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and the National Commission for Women, were exempted. Therefore, all these institutions which Parliament -- I am saying 'Parliament' -- in its wisdom thought should be exempted, were exempted.

SHRI DINESH TRIVEDI: But not with retrospective effect...(interruptions)...

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: There may be a genuine difference of opinion on this side and the other side because it does not suit their requirement if some of the hon. Members sitting in the Treasury Benches get some benefit, but we see the obvious politics behind it. We are all politicians. One Member of the Trinamool Congress says they should all be disqualified and some BJP MP says they should all be disqualified; it is unethical. Do we seem to be saints to accept whatever they say? We have our own policy on this issue and that is that no Member -- I am saying 'no Member'-- irrespective of any party affiliation should be disqualified unless it is very, very necessary.

Some people tried to confuse the issue of corruption with disqualification. Shrimati Brindaji forcefully opposed this. I would also like to take this opportunity to say that it is not proper to confuse these two issues. Bribery is a serious crime in parliamentary life. But in the case of disqualification of a Member -- he serves his constituency or heads a Zilla Parishad or any local Municipal authority or any Wakf Board. Here it is not the kind of corruption that they are alleging.

DR. MURLI MANOHAR JOSHI: What kind of corruption is that?

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mr. Minister, you may go ahead. I have not allowed him.

DR. MURLI MANOHAR JOSHI: May I know from the hon. Minister what type of corruption is that? ...(interruptions)...

林 埊置殖种谉 : り苤, 喼 撝甑指 埴 更状挚之 坳 撞之种 ..(镜志脂种)..?

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 曋株恐 曋, 粗 喼坳 弥执之株 熤株 仓株恢 弥埴熤 奇狱, 恢曜埴 喼 嚠 仓摀种 粗 恐肿粗恢 粗熤 泣株噵 ..(镜志脂种)...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mr. Law Minister, if anybody asks you a question without my permission, please, do not respond.

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Mr. Deputy Chairman, Sir, they said something about Mahabharata in the debate. It is the same thing that is happening. 粗 曋株恐 曋 埴 仓浲 弥创种 埴更熤 奇狱 抵 持 株-熤弋 仓指 泣謭弥 埴株 更株埴 埴 埴株卓挚 粗 V陞 喼 嚐之株 拙肢 局辎种 骑 喼罡 泣粗 弥指 埓窒 喼 恢株葜蛛 埴 弥创种 埴更熤 喼 骑, 恢曜埴 曋仓 泣粗 株 仓譄 埴泣 坳 谆謰 喼熤 骑, 熤株 恢株葜蛛 埴株 堐种熤 骑鼌 抵泣 泣 泣株 撝肿泣媴 ..(镜志脂种).. 粗锂株 喼埴 仓譄 弥惝诌 ...(镜志脂种)..

淈. 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 抵泣 撞只坫 葜恢熤 祁鼌 喼 嚸舟 弥肿仓熤 埴更 弥埴熤 骑鼌 ..(镜志脂种).. 粗锂株 熤株 喼曋 熤埴 综诌 埴株 堐种抵 泣 泣鄥 ..(镜志脂种)..

林 埊置殖种谉 : 喼 仓钭汓媴 ..(镜志脂种)..

淈. 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 粗锂株 埴持 喼埴株 持 堐种 埴 埴株卓挚 泣 埴 ..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 撝恢株 粗 粗之譄种 奇狱...(镜志脂种).. 恢曜埴 粗锂株 喒 曋 埴 仓譄 仓浲挈 种 弥 弥惝诌 V邊 ..(镜志脂种)...

淈. 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 弥 坳 弥指挈 弥创种桩譄 弥玫 嚸 仓譄 埴 葜局制 り 弥埴熤 骑 综 粗锂株 埴持 综诌 埴株 泣 堐种抵謪 ..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 抵泣钟 嬯弥 更疮指 泣 泣株 撝肿泣 综 泣粗 嬠 ゆ指挈 埴 弥创种  埴鸽鼌 喒 曋 嬠 懼訖 仓株恢, 粗锂株 埉舟犏 嬠-嬠 恐菠 埴株 谆值种 喼罡 粗 撝制鼰种 V 综 粗 嚠舟 仓熤譄种 尩种胱埴 泣粗 株蛛 恢烛 状肿脵 更脐 骑鼌 ..(镜志脂种)..

淈. 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 嗇指 弥 粗 朴诌 埴 便拄肿浲种  泣蛛 喼罡 泣粗 弥指 弥粗抵 喼坳 葜映诌更 持致洲 弥惝蛛 熤株 妆 尩种 仓譄 更脐诌..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 撝恢株 泣粗 朴 恢隉株 骑鼌 .. .(镜志脂种)..

淈. 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 粗锂株 熤株 嚐之种 泣 弥局只 鏀 V 综 嗇指 嬯弥 埴更之 泣 熤株 垲种 埴更之? ..(镜志脂种)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 粗 熤株 抵泣 撝制 更泣 V 综 粗 曋株 V株浲 仓沏鼰 仓譄 曋之譄种 奇狱, 埫株 粗 泣謭弥 粗 更苤 ゆ狱, 熤肿埴 弥持 嫶织诌曋 埴株 嚸 仓譄 埴 笾之 泣株 综 喼曋 泣謭弥 粗 曋株 粗制罨 瞍 综种 葜抵 祁 喼罡 讜置舟 粗泗 更 持 V株浲-V株浲 喢指 泣株 恢葜, 局泣 抵泣 V 综 埴泣 埴株囋 暤种 葜恢熤 埴执 熤株 泣 泣株 更泣 祁鼌 泣粗指挈 持謬 抵泣钟 仓顨挈 骑, 曋株 综 局昝欬 -

仓虞种恢 弥 弥钟弥 撝惝舟 喼熤 骑鼌 抵 持 垷之株 泣 弥创种桩譄 嫶织诌 骑, 讜譄之株 拼 嚞指 弥 喼熤 骑 抵 粗泣指聶尹 弥 喼熤 骑鼌 抵泣 埴泣 综 抵 埴株囋 * 埴更 更脐 骑, they are involved in corruption, these are not proper, parliamentary, words to be used for hon. Members. If there is anybody liable for disqualification, you may say that they would suffer disqualification. But to say that they are * or * is not right. I am saying that proper words must be used. Now, I would tell you that there are not very many MPs from the Treasury Benches.

(Contd. by 3T/HK)

HK-NB/3t/5.15

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ (CONTD.): Let me tell you that Dr. Karan Singh is one of the most outstanding parliamentarians and there was a doubt about ICCR. Your own party MP, Najmaji, had been occupying this office. If we are exempting it and if it is being exempted for the sake of safety, what is the harm about it? All these institutions have to

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

* Expunged as ordered by the Chair.


be exempted for public good and there is nothing personal in it. You are saying that in order to save this Government, all this is being done. Then, I cannot counter you by a counter-argument that you want that we should not do whatever helps our Government. Jayaji's case was very unfortunate case. But I told my friend, Mr. Amar Singh, if you had brought to my notice that the case is pending with the Election Commission, there could be ways and means to help her out. But she contested her case. ..(Interruptions)..

SHRI AMAR SINGH: It was difficult to get an appointment from a Congress Minister. ..(Interruptions).. I respect you, but it is difficult to get appointment from a Congress Minister. ..(Interruptions).. How could I? ..(Interruptions).. You don't say that. ..(Interruptions)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 喼 鏀 更脐 骑 综 尩种 泣株 弥埴熤 V ... (镜志脂种) 弥阕 ... (镜志脂种)

SHRI ARUN SHOURIE: What are those ways and means? ..(Interruptions)..

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Legal advice. ..(Interruptions)..

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: I am telling you. I am answering you. In Amar Singh's case, he has sought time from the Election Commission saying that he wants full particulars of the alleged disqualification, and any lawyer who knows law takes this preliminary objection to a petition which disqualifies he or she. But if you get a case decided summarily, it is the fault of lawyer.

SHRI S.S. AHLUWALIA: She got seven months' extension. ..(Interruptions)..

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : 曋煟株指 曋, 曋更 弥惝种 埴更株 ... (镜志脂种)

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Anyway, the Congress is not involved in this. ..(Interruptions).. Therefore, I am refuting these accusations that we are responsible to disqualify any hon. Member. We have no ill-will against any Member.

林 驻菥謺值 子弥悠 : 局 AICC 坳 粗氩指 泣 V陞

林 朴指曋 持指曋 : AICC 坳 粗氩指 熤株 泣粗指挈 喆指 孛制 曋 持 V陞 抵 泣粗指挈 愀 株脽 骑 ... (镜志脂种)

林 驻菥謺值 孛制 : V ?

林 喆指 孛制 : AICC 埴 粗氩指 熤株 粗泗株 林 喥证 欔  仓值种 V, he is my political father.

林 埊置殖种谉 : 啿 抵泣 喼弥 粗 尩种 撝恢 更泣 祁? .... (镜志脂种)

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I am only saying that some allegations have been made and it is my duty, as a Minister, to refute and deny them. Otherwise, they will go unrefuted. We are not responsible and we are not, at all, keen that any member should be disqualified. This is the feeling which the Government has got, and we do not want that any Member should be disqualified unnecessarily. Normally, I do not go to anybody's House and talk to him unnecessarily. 燘ut since there was a keen desire to help out any Member who is getting unnecessary harassed, so we found out various people, but I am not lobbying for getting this Bill passed. So if, at all, I talked to certain people of various political parties, I talked it sincerely and I maintained that I am not taking any partisan attitude because one member told me that I will lose my ministership if I do not pass this Bill. This is the type of insinuations which were made. I don't deserve this kind of treatment. I have been too long a Minister. I have seen this Ministry thrice. I have been the Law Minister during Rajiv Gandhi's Government, Narsimha Rao's Government and now in the present Government. I have five consecutive terms in Parliament. I don't look to favours. They come to me for my service to my party and to my leader.牋 (Contd. by 3u/KSK)

AKG/KSK/5.20/3U

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ (CONTD): And, I am proud of it and we have -- I would like to put on record -- demonstrated that our leaders have something special. They do demonstrate ethical values. If our leader resigned from the Lok Sabha seat, that was in the highest tradition of this, and I think, she has been returned by the people with a proper reply to the other side. So, we are proud of it.牋 Now, in this particular Bill, we have not hidden anything from the House. We have said 40 and odd MPs are likely to be affected and then more MPs are feeling. I can give you a list of 15 more people who have approached me, some of them from the Bhartiya Janata Party also, but I said, "Go to your leaders. If they say, I will add your names."

But, this is a problem which this House is facing, and this House must take cognisance of this. If there can be any other way to deal with this, our Government will be willing to deal with this and we will request that we should rise above narrow party political considerations and help this to restore the kind of confidence in parliamentary functioning.牋 I am only pained, Sir, being a senior Member of this House, whenever we legislate, we light-heartedly disturb the House proceedings and harp on other false excuses. This is what I have seen.

牋牋牋 Therefore, I have replied to all Members. There is a provision in the Constitution under article 102, which permits Parliament to exempt and if Parliament exempts, it always exempts after discussion, and if there was an attempt by the Government to involve consensus, that was sincerity, not by motive, and if some of them are on our side, and some of them are on the other, that has also been included. That is why, the list is inflated.牋 So, there is no sinister design in getting this Bill passed. It is in public good, for saving public money, saving public inconvenience and I commend that the Bill be passed.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I shall put the Amendment moved by Shri Mule Venkata Mysura Reddy for reference of the Bill to Select Committee, Rajya Sabha.牋 He is not present.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Sir, my name is also there.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: No, you have not moved the amendment. He has moved the amendment and he is not present.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Sir, let me submit...(Interruptions). Both of us have given the notice for amendment. When he moved the amendment, I was present in the House.牋 Where was the need for me to rise to move the motion when he had already moved? ...(Interruptions)... I was physically present. I signed it.

犆钟弥叩 埴值衷 粗印种恢抵 粗 更謺抵 粗印诌 (林 弥愀挈恐 撝诸更) : 讜置舟犏 执 埴 粗株恐 泣株熤 祁 抵 喆蛛淈粗霗 泣株熤 祁, 弥脂种更拗熤: 局泣 粗婢 埴更熤 祁鼌 晗曋霗 熤株 仓舟 弥玫 持 泣株熤 骑鼌 ... (镜志脂种) ...

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY:牋 I have signed it...(Interruptions).

林 埊置殖种谉 : 执 祁, 恢曜埴 嚠泣蛛 粗婢 泣 综种 祁 ! He has not moved. He could have also moved.

林 嬅.嬅. 喥帚局肿恢抵 : 局 抵泣盅 晗曋霗 V ... (镜志脂种) ...

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: When he moved, where was the need for me to move.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY:牋 When the Member has moved, what was the need for me also to move the motion. I was present. There was no need for it.

林 嬅.嬅. 喥帚局肿恢抵 : 弥 粗 弥更坫株欬 沏鼏 祁 ... (镜志脂种) ...

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN:牋 See, I am going by rules and that is what has been in practice.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY:牋 Sir, you give a ruling. It will set a bad precedent. If you give a ruling, I will sit down.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN:牋 You have not moved the amendment, how can I allow you?

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Let me submit, Sir. Both of us have signed and he moved.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I am not saying that. Your name is there but you did not move. See, if there are two-three people who give notice for amendment, two or three people can also move the motion, and then you can take up.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: But, Sir, when the amendment had been moved already....(Interruptions).

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN:牋 I will read 'mode of moving an amendment'. "When a motion that a Bill be taken into consideration has been carried, any Member, when called upon by the Chairman, may move an amendment to the Bill, of which he has previously given notice."

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Yes, I have given notice.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: You have given notice. When I called upon to move the motion....(Interruptions).

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Sir, I have given notice...(Interruptions).牋 You have not called me.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I called.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: No, Sir. You have called Mr. Mule Venkata Mysura Reddy. He moved the motion.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mysura Reddy and Ravula Chandra Sekar Reddy. I called both.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Sir, he moved the motion.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN:牋 Then, between both of you, you decided that he will move the motion. 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 (followed by 3w)

GSP-HMS/5.25/3w

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Sir, I have signed the Motion. (Interruptions)

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: An amendment moved may, by leave of the Council, but not otherwise, be withdrawn, on the request of the moving member. If an amendment has been proposed to an amendment, the original amendment shall not be withdrawn until the amendment proposed itself is disposed of. So, I am sorry. He should be the person. Now, I put the question. (Interruptions) I have given the ruling.

SHRI RAVULA CHANDRA SEKAR REDDY: Having moved the Motion, I am not being given the opportunity, Sir.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: You have not moved the Motion, Mr. Reddy. You have not moved the Motion. There is a Rule and the Rule is clear. (Interruptions)

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: The question is:

 

That the Bill further to amend the Parliament (Prevention of Disqualification) Act, 1959, be referred to a Select Committee of the Rajya Sabha consisting of the following members (names of members to be given at the time of making the motion) with instructions to report by the first day of the next session of the Rajya Sabha.

 

The Motion was negatived.

SHRI DINESH TRIVEDI: Sir, I want division. (Interruptions)

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: For what? On this Motion? (Interruptions) He has moved the Motion. Motion is to refer it to Select Committee. That has been negatived.

I shall now put the Motion moved by Shri Hansraj Bhardwaj to vote. The question is:

That the Parliament (Prevention of Disqualification) Amendment Bill, 2006, as passed by Lok Sabha, be taken into consideration.

燭he Motion was adopted.

SHRI S.S. AHLUWALIA: Sir, this is murder of democracy. (Interruptions)

SHRIMATI SUSHMA SWARAJ: Sir, we shall not be party to...(Interruptions)...

(At this stage, some hon. Members left the Chamber)

 

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Now, we shall take up Clause-by-Clause consideration of the Bill.

 

Clauses 2 to 4 were added to the Bill.

Clause 1, the Enacting Formula and the Title were added to the Bill.

 

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Now, the hon. Minister.

SHRI HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ: Sir, I move:

That the Bill be passed.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Now,...(Interruptions)...

SHRI DINESH TRIVEDI: Sir, I want division. It is my right. It is my constitutional right. I object to it. Why are you not giving division? Sir, it is unfair. I object to this, Sir. This is my constitutional right. Why can't you give me division? On what point of law, Sir...(Interruptions)... This is my parliamentary right. Even one Member can ask for division.牋 On which law, are you refusing me? On which law...(Interruptions)...

SHRI SHAHID SIDDIQUI: Sir, he is right. (Interruptions) How can he be denied his right?

SHRI DINESH TRIVEDI: Sir, it is my right.

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: I accept his request and there will be a division. 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 (CONTD. BY SK-3X)

SK-YSR-KLG/5.35/3X-3Y

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: The question is:

That the Bill be passed.

 

The House divided.

 

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Subject to correction

牋牋牋 Ayes : 109

Noes : 03

 

The motion was adopted.

(Ends)

MESSAGE FROM LOK SABHA

THE RESERVE BANK OF INDIA (AMENDMENT) BILL, 2006.

SECRETARY-GENERAL: Sir, I have to report to the House the following message received from the Lok Sabha, signed by the Secretary-General of the Lok Sabha:

"In accordance with the provisions of rule 96 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha, I am directed to enclose the Reserve Bank of India (Amendment) Bill, 2006, as passed by Lok Sabha at its sitting held on the 17th May, 2006."

 

牋牋牋 Sir, I lay a copy of the Bill on the Table.

(Ends)

 

THE CESS LAWS (REPEALING AND AMENDING) BILL, 2006

 

THE MINISTER OF STATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY (SHRI JAIRAM RAMESH): Sir, I beg to move:

That the Bill to repeal certain enactments and to amend certain other enactments relating to levy of cess on certain items, as passed by Lok Sabha, be taken into consideration.

 

The question was put and the motion was adopted

 

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Now, we shall take up clause-by-clause consideration of the Bill.

Clauses 2-5, the First Schedule, and the Second Schedule were added to the Bill.

Clause 1, the Enacting Formula, and the Title were added to the Bill.

 

SHRI JAIRAM RAMESH: 燬ir, I move:

牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 That the Bill be returned.

The question was put and the motion was adopted.

(Ends)

 

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Special Mentions.

 

RE. ANOTHER MILITANTS' ATTACK IN DODA DISTRICT (contd.)

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 (垻指 悉挈恐) : 埊置殖种谉 曋, 喼曋 株泣更 粗 粗锂株 弥 粗 淈株淈 坳 営更 曋株 懼欬謰 沏鼑 骑, 埫舟犏 仓指挈 粗 弥更埴指 埴 种 喼坶欬 综种 V 综 喼曋 持 局泣钟 葜详隂 啓钲 沏鼖 骑, 讜置执蛛 粗闊抵 沏鼑 喼罡 恢株葜 懼值只 沏鼖 骑鼌 更弥蛛 粗之之诌抵 葜槠 粗印诌 曋  弥 粗 泣粗 恢株葜蛛 埴株 喼烤种弥 驻种 V 综 局泣钟 弥愀种 坳 熤诸更 更 娓 镜志置V 埴 曋 更泣 祁 喼罡 喼曋 现熤:埴只 持 粗之之诌抵 更踔 粗印诌 曋  抵泣 埴泣 综 娓挈 熤诸更 更 弥愀种 埴 镜志置V 祁鼌 熤株 嬠 羡更 弥 泣粗 喼烤置熤 V 综 啿 坳 弥更埴指 喼罡 更謺抵 弥更埴指, 株蛛 局泣钟 埴 酌V谉 更 娓 桩值钟≈拗 更苤胼株 喼罡 啿 嬯弥 ゃ鼞衷欬謰 泣 泣蛛葜邊牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 牋牋 3曋隂/嬠犏 更 喼葜

VKK-AKA/3z/5.40

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 (畚种葜熤) : 粗泗株 仓沏鼰 苤辘 坳 弥郑 埴泣 浲鼰种 祁 综 喼曋 持 懼欬 沏鼑詤 粗 粗之之诌抵 葜槠 粗印诌 曋 弥 抵泣 葜銜痔肿更恐 埴褂种 综 嬠 熤株 局 抵泣 仓熤謰 综 喼曋 埴 酌V谉 尩种 祁, 抵 懼欬 垲株 沏鼑 喼罡 ゆ指 抵泣 综 持拙致抵 粗 抵泣  泣株, 嚸舟犏 谆謰 喼 尩种 埴粗 垰 更脐 骑? 尩种 埫株 喼 讻欬仓 嬜更抵 懼株茁譄 埴更坳 柄诸曋 坳 泣局只株 埴鸽株? 喼 尩种 埴鸽株? 坳 尩种 嚸执蛛 讜执粗辘更 恢贻种, 更謺抵 弥更埴指 埴株 尩种 喼り り种 喼罡 埉 恢株葜蛛 埴 弥愀种 埴 尩种 镜志置V 埴戈种? 局 恢株葜 埴泣熤 骑 综 泣粗 啹之株 懼更 垲株 曋謰, 泣粗 淈株淈 弥 啹之株 葜钟局蛛 粗 垲株 曋謰訁 抵泣 埴泣 葜抵 V 综 局泣钟 拙只株曋 埴粗隀曋 仓謬 葜囋 骑, 粗泗株 仓沏鼰 苤辘 坳 弥郑 埴泣 浲鼰种 祁 综 仓沏鼰 弥 葜钟局蛛 粗 局 喅诌 泣 仓 骑 喼罡 讜之 葜钟局蛛 粗 仓謬 葜囋 V, 局 局挈 葜钟局 泣 骑, 曋泣钟 喼局康舟鸁种 祁鼌 粗旮 喼弥 啴帚更株 综 埴粗 弥 埴粗 喼 喼曋 弥更埴指 埴 坫鷶 嬯弥 咦熤 埴 埢恢贶 埴鸽 讜置置株 综 抵 懼欬謰 持拙致抵 粗 泣 泣蛛葜, 埴泣 熤株 嚸舟 営熤 埴更 撝肿泣 喼罡 淈株淈 娓 熤更泣 弥 弥愀踔熤 更脐种, 淈株淈 坳 喼弥置 坳 葜钟局 弥愀踔熤 更齐株, 恢株葜 局泣钟 弥 恢值之 泣 埴鸽株, 啴抵V 熤株 抵泣 撝罨蛛曋 祁 弥更埴指 坳 谆謰 -- 更弥蛛 喼 埴泣, 喼曋 更踔 粗印诌 曋  埴泣 喼罡 喼熤盂种 喼曋 喼埴更 懼欬 埴更 葜媴牋 抵泣 粗 弥粗糁熤 奇狱 综 り 坳 谆謰 持 喼罡 弥更埴指 坳 谆謰 持 仓沏鼰 泣 負譄之诌抵 拙致值 祁 喼罡 り 埴株 負譄种 祁 嚸 更厾 埴泣 熤株 嚠 懼欬謫蛛 埴 営熤 泣株 撝肿泣媴

牋牋牋 嚸肿恢 粗 喼弥 啴帚更株 埴褂种 综 嚸 弥硬钟 粗 喼 坫鷶 埴齐鼌

(弥粗织熤)

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 弥更, 嬠 尰株赘柄坳之 粗 持 鏀种 撝制鼰种 奇狱

林 埊置殖种谉 : 泣, 抵泣 讻株欬 泣 祁鼌 埉泣蛛 更状挚之 粗钟葜 V, 埉舟 更状挚之 驻种 葜抵謪牋 He only wants a piece of information.

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 (垻指 悉挈恐) : 淈0 曋株恐 曋  曋株 仓譄 埴泣, 泣粗 熤株 埫舟犏 弥郑 啹之株 埴株 弥硬吱 埴更熤 沏鼖 嬠 仓譄 埴泣 撝制鼰株 骑 综 粗之之诌抵 更踔 粗印诌 曋  喼曋 弥悴制 嬠 峡 坳 垻指 粗 埴泣 综 曋创宙-埴看诌更 撞只坫 镁州衷 仓 更泣 祁鼌 尩种 粗 嚸舟 嚸肿恢 镁州衷 粗之宙 综 局泣钟 更株曋 恢株葜 粗更 更脐 骑 喼罡 埫舟 更踔 泣 泣株 更泣?

林 埊置殖种谉 : 抵泣 尰株赘柄坳之 泣 祁鼌

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 埴仓 熤埴 抵泣 弥悠更 泣株熤 更脐种, 埴泣  埴泣 熤株 嚸舟 脵虔 埴鸽株? 泣粗 坳只 嚐之种 泣 埴泣 撝制鼰株 骑 综 抵泣 过埴 撝肿泣媴 嚐之诌 仓浲 懼欬 泣株 葜囋, 淈株淈 弥戤种 坳 泣局只株 尩种 泣 泣株 更泣 祁? 泣粗 抵泣 曋之之种 撝制鼰株 骑 综 弥戤种 坳 泣局只株 埴仓 埴鸽株?

MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: Mr. Home Minister, would you like to respond?

葜槠 粗印诌 (林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢) : 林叽之炙, 粗泗株 曋株 粗只宙粗譄 状只诌 祁, 泣粗 曋创宙-埴看诌更 弥更埴指 弥 粗只宙粗譄 恢 祁, 埫舟犏 粗銦种撞舟 淈株淈 坳 置 喼曋-仓謺宙 坳 葜钟局蛛 坳 坫鷶 恢株葜 恢謰 葜 V 喼罡 埉舟 弥榆抵 株-熤弋 弥诸 抵 嚸置株 暤种 V邊 埉舟 恢之株 坳 株 埀挈康 V, 嬯弥 仓熤值种 葜抵 祁, 啿 局泣 埴泣钟 熤埴 弥泣 祁, 抵泣 曋之舟更 状只之株 坳 仓证 熤 恢葜贻种厾 嬠 熤株 淈株淈 喼罡 埇执织帚更 粗 曋株 沏鼏 V, 埫舟 拙指戡 埴更 坳 谆謰 局 恢謰 葜 V 喼罡 ゆ指 仓譄 曋株 泣粗埴株 仓熤謬 葜囋, 局泣 抵泣 祁 综 局泣钟 更 喼 坳 仓证 曋仓 埉舟 局肿弥 曋之株 坳 谆謰 埴泣 葜抵, 熤株 埉泣蛛 埴泣 综 拙只株曋 埴粗曜欬抵钟 仓謬 曋 更泣 骑 喼罡 埉 埴粗曜欬抵蛛 坳 営更 泣粗埴株 持 恐更咣 泣株 祁, 嚸肿恢 泣粗 抵泣 更泣 撝制朦葜陞 埫诌 弥粗抵 局泣钟 更 曋株 恢株葜 V, 埉舟犏 夲更 嬠 葜详隂 憋 葜抵 喼罡 埫 葜详隂 粗, 粗泗株 曋株 粗只宙粗譄  葜囋 祁 泣粗指 嚠柄指株恐 坳 弥株弥 弥, 10-15 恢株葜 曋艽诌 沏鼖 骑, 苤憧肿埴么譄诌 弥 综诌 曋之 埴 局泣钟 更 阚种 泣 沏鼏 祁, 嬯弥 粗泗株 仓熤值种 葜抵 祁 喼罡 阕恢弥, 曋株 局泣钟 更 祁, 局泣 嚠柄指株恐 恢贳 泣粗埴株 り 更泣 祁鼌

牋牋牋 嬠 仓譄 泣粗埴株 种 粗 更苤 曋湖更 祁 喼罡 局泣 抵泣 祁 综 嗇指 泣粗 埫 嚮种坳 粗 曋謰 喼罡 埫 嚮种坳 埴株 り蛛 熤株 泣粗埴株 熤 撝恢贻种 综 局泣钟 更 曋泣钟 酌謱抵阕更欬 泣粗埴株 现昃种嚊 埴更 祁, 局泣 曋葜泣 综 羡更 埴 祁鼌 局泣钟 更 泣肿浲种 骑 喼罡 糁肿浲种 持 骑 喼罡 局泣钟 曋株 葜钟局 仓弥 沏鼖 骑, 局 曋蠲株 株 嬜更抵 粗 葜钟局 泣株熤 骑, 局蠲株 泣 骑 - 400, 500 抵 1000 懼更 坳 葜钟局 泣 骑, 局 4 懼更 坳, 5 懼更 坳 葜钟局 骑, 嬯弥 葜钟局 骑 喼罡 娓挈 泣譀忘 更 鳖株 沏鼖 葜钟局 骑鼌 葜钟局蛛 埴 弥榆抵 局泣钟 泣曋指 粗 骑鼌 抵泣 曋株 埴粗曜欬抵钟 仓之株 埴 埴执 祁, 讜之舟犏 仓指挈 粗 局泣钟 坳 粗丬抵 粗印诌 曋  粗泗株 镁值钟 仓株恢 V 综 泣粗 埴粗曜欬抵钟 暤种 仓謰虞株, 埴粗曜欬抵蛛 坳 恢株葜蛛 埴株 暤种 熤芫种泣 る株 喼罡 泣粗 泣祝值种更 持 り 更脐 骑 喼罡 曋蠲种 综 埴恢 抵泣钟 撝撝衷 坳 弥粗抵 仓熤值种 葜抵 V 综 仓沏鼰 啌旉 泣祝值种更, AK 47 曋蠲株 泣祝值种更 埉舟 り株 撝肿泣媴 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 ('4A/SCH' 更 曋指)

SCH/5.45/4A

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 (畚种葜熤): 嚸 弥硬钟 粗 泣粗 埉齐 埴泣 V 综 喼埴株 曋蠲诌 弥阕局 泣株, 喼 局蠲种 埴咦曋媴 曋株 坫鷶 持 喼 埴鸽株, 泣粗 喼埴株 埫执蛛 粗 る株 恢曜埴 局泣钟 更 埫 弥粗抵 持 粗锂株 埴泣 V 综 喼 讜之舟 泣祝值种更 り 更脐 骑, 局 埉 泣祝值种更蛛 埴 埊值种贻 恢株葜蛛 埴 弥愀种 坳 谆謰 埴鸽株 抵 综诌 啴抵 撝邥痔 坳 谆謰 埴鸽株, 嚸舟犏 夲更 持 喼埴株 种 更苤 泣株葜謪 嚸诌谆謰 局泣钟 更 抵泣 埴粗曜欬抵钟 仓之株 埴 埴执 综种 葜抵謪  曋之株 埉泣蛛 综鸁之诌 埴粗曜欬抵钟 仓謬 骑, 100 坳 埴更卟 埴粗曜欬抵钟 嬠 曋葜泣 更 骑 喼罡 涥鼫忘 弥诸 坳 埴更卟 ゆ指 曋葜泣 更 骑鼌 嬠 曋葜泣 埴 埴粗曜欬抵蛛 粗 弥仓 状只种埴更 650 坳 埴更卟 恢株葜 骑 喼罡 ゆ指 曋葜泣 更 400 坳 埴更卟 恢株葜 骑, 嚸 熤更泣 弥 局泣钟 更 嚸 羡更 埴 镜志置V 泣株 更泣 祁鼌 恢曜埴 曋创宙 嬀钟 埴看诌更 粗 泣粗 曋株 仓に埴么譄诌 り之株 埴株 状只譄诌 祁, 局泣 抵泣 祁 综 旣株欔-旣株欔 仓摀种 埴株 埴浲 曋 更泣 祁, 埉舟犏 泣郑种 粗 葜详隂 驻种 曋 更泣 祁 喼罡 埉齐 埴泣 曋 更泣 祁 综 撝恢熤-撝恢熤 喼 嚸株 埴泣 彪 株 喼罡 局 仓摀株 葜详隂 憋 埴更 桩舟 曋譄株 骑鼌 埉 仓摀种 埴株 埴浲种 嬀钟 埉 更 柄值指 埴更 仓沏鼰 粗阕扣 泣株 曋譄种 祁, 尩种胱埴 局 仓摀株 妆 葜值植 泣株 曋譄株 骑鼌牋

ゆ指 仓譄 曋株 局泣钟 更 酌謾曋 粗 泣株 更泣 祁 局泣 抵泣 祁 综 曋株 粗株欬鸽 抵 埴指朦 骑, 埉舟犏 啴更 仓烛床 更苤 曋 更脐 骑 喼罡 嬯弥 仓烛床弥 埴株 局泣钟 埴泣 更 持 旣株浲 驻种 曋譄种 祁鼌 抵泣 埴值衷 局泣钟 更 泣株 更泣 祁, 嚸舟 局曋泣 弥 持 仓沏鼰 粗阕扣 泣株 葜抵 祁鼌 局泣钟 埴 曋株 踔辍 祁, 局泣钟 更 曋株 状肿恢櫼 祁, 曋仓 泣粗 局泣钟 更 葜 V, 熤仓 泣粗 嚸诌 仓譄 埴 撝撝衷 埴 V 综 状肿恢櫼 坳 曋株 脵挈恐 局泣钟 更 骑, 株 抵 熤弋 粗呋 坳 柄置只株 更 状肿恢櫼 坳鸂 脵挈恐 祁, 曋株 恢株葜 局泣钟 更 更泣熤 骑, 局 喕州-喕州 曋葜泣 更 更泣熤 骑鼌 局 恢株葜 泣譀忘 坳 仓邠 粗 更泣 更脐 骑,  熤株 局 恢株葜 夲更 埴 熤更柄 骑 喼罡  泣 邠株 埴 熤更柄 骑, 局 仓邠 粗 更泣 更脐 骑 熤肿埴 啹之种 埴执 埴更 弥垭鷧 局泣钟 坳 恢株葜蛛 埴 埴泣 V 综 仓邠 粗 更泣 坳 仓曋謰 曋株 泣譀忘 埴 弥仓弥 暤种 売鷵种囋 祁, 埫 嫰株屆 坳 夲更 抵驻 局 曋舟 更齐 熤株 暤种 曋葜泣 更 り 弥埴熤 骑鼌牋 泣粗 埉齐 埴泣 综 喼埴 仓譄 撞只坫 弥泣 祁, 恢曜埴 曋仓 泣粗 埉 恢株葜蛛 坳 弥郑 嚸 仓譄 埴 撝撝衷 埴 熤株 埉泣蛛 泣粗 仓熤值种 综 夲更 曋之株 坳 仓证 嗇指 邠株 坫鷶 泣株 更泣 泣株 熤株 熤愀熤 喼 持 粗阕扣 泣株 曋謰葜謪 嚸肿恢 泣粗 嚸株 仓邠 粗 更苤 祁鼌 熤仓 泣粗 埉置株 埴泣 综 嗇指 喼 夲更 更泣熤 祁 熤株 喼埴株 撝指 熤更柄 り之株 埴株 状只株葜, 恢曜埴 抵驻 仓邠 粗 更齐株 熤仓 喼 坳只 嬠 泣 熤更柄 弥 り蛛葜陞 抵驻 喼 曋之株 坳 谆謰 埴株囋 更置熤 仓之种 祁 熤株 埫株 谆謰 泣粗 镜志置V 埴更 る株 嚸 熤更泣 弥 泣粗 抵 弥仓 撝邥痔 局泣钟 更 埴更 曋 更脐 骑鼌

局泣钟 更 状肿恢櫼 埴烛恢疵 持 仓溚 葜 骑鼌 更踔 粗印诌 持 局泣钟 葜 V陞 喼埴 曋之舟更 坳 谆謰 粗 抵泣 仓熤之种 撝制嬗种 综 曋株 泣粗指 囉欬更羁之只 仓烛浽 祁, 埫舟犏 夲更 仓邒弥嫳 祁鼌 局泣钟 更 柄诸曋 泣 祁, 喼粗 泣 祁, 局泣钟 更 仓邒弥嫳 祁 喼罡 曋株 恢謬 喼虮 塾鷻尹株恢 祁, 局泣钟 更 喼粗 祁鼌 恢謬 喼虮 塾鷻尹株恢 坳 曋亭埴 坳 曋株 嬜更抵謺痔 骑, 局泣钟 更 喼粗 埴 弥榆抵 仓沏鼰 喿埴 赘种拗 粗 泣 祁鼌 曋创宙 嬀钟 埴看诌更 粗 泣粗 曋株 镜志置V 埴 祁 局泣 抵泣 祁 综 局泣钟 埴 弥愀种 埴 讜执粗辘更 曋创宙 嬀钟 埴看诌更 埴 阕恢弥 埴株  祁 喼罡 埉舟 粗 坳 谆謰 泣粗 仓浲 弥榆抵 粗 旮状肿恢櫼 柄株倜謺痔 持  骑, 讜置舟犏 営更 仓邒弥嫳 持 祁, 弥邌指诌嫳 持 祁鼌 喼罡 持 喿埴 弥榆抵 粗 泣粗 埉齐 持陼种 祁 喼罡 弥郑 泣 弥郑 喼粗 坳 恢株葜蛛 埴株 持 埉舟 粗 坳 谆謰 持陼种 祁鼌 抵 曋株 弥指 柄株倜謺痔 骑 - 喼粗, 旮状肿恢櫼 柄株倜謺痔 喼罡 脵挈欬 阕恢弥, 嚠舟犏 営更 埴株喼蛸淈昕之 坳 谆謰 嬠 埴粗隀 仓謬 祁, 讜置舟 执 抵孀柄謬淈 埴粗钟淈 祁鼌 嚸 抵孀柄謬淈 埴粗钟淈 粗 喼粗 坳 喼蜃柄弥弥 泣株熤 骑, 局泣钟 坳 嬜更抵 坳 埴粗钟淈更 泣株熤 骑, 局泣钟 埴 阕恢弥 坳 淈邥诌 泣株熤 骑 喼罡 弥郑 泣唿 泣粗指 罡状肿恢櫼 柄株倜謺痔 坳 恢株葜 泣株熤 骑鼌 嚸 埴粗隀 埴 撝甑指诸卓织 埫 更謺抵 坳 粗丬抵粗印诌 埴株 埴更 坳 谆謰 埴泣 葜抵 祁 喼罡 弥郑 泣 埉齐 抵泣 持 埴泣 葜抵 祁 综 曋仓 持 喼埴株 喼粗 抵 罡状肿恢櫼 柄株倜謺痔 埴 抵 阕恢弥 埴 讻恢烛嫶蛛欬 埴更 埴 曋湖更熤 泣株, 喼 埫株 埴鸽鼌

喼曋 持 曋仓 讻嵇弥 状肿脵 仓株恢 更脐 V, 熤仓 粗 抵泣 更 V 喼罡 镁值钟 持 粗锂株 仓沏鼰 仓指 仓熤值种 祁 综 局泣钟 埴 曋株 喼熤盂种 祁, 局泣 娓 熤更泣 弥 苤煷 泣 沏鼏 祁鼌 抵泣 苤煷 泣株 葜抵 祁, 嬯弥  熤株 讻嵇弥 状肿脵 弥制  抵泣 埴泣 祁 综 喼罡  泣 粗锂株 嬯弥 埴泣 祁, 局泣 埴粗 喚挚抵 沏鼏 祁 喼罡 仓沏鼰 泣 熤埴 埴粗 沏鼏 祁鼌 埴持-埴持 嬯弥 泣株熤 祁 综 嗇指 泣粗 局泣钟 更 曋舟 更謭記 欔只 埴烛朦弥 埴更熤 骑, 熤株 坫鷶 恢株葜 埫舟犏 总只种柄 撝恢 曋譄株 骑鼌 牋牋牋 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 MCM/4B 更 畚挚:

MCM-MKS/4B/5-50

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 (畚种葜熤) : 嗇指 嚮株尶之 沏鼖 骑, 赘鼤只欬 喼 葜 骑 熤株 埫舟犏 仓指挈 粗 坫鷶 恢株葜蛛 埴株 嬯弥 恢葜熤 祁 综 抵泣钟 更 恐钟谉 仓 沏鼑 祁 喼罡 嚐之株 恢株葜 嗇指 局株欬 埴更 更脐 骑 熤株 局泣 恐钟谉 埴 曋株 粗制罨 仓 沏鼏 祁, 嬯弥 仓熤值种 曋 更泣 祁 综 局泣 葜恢熤 祁, 仓熤之株 坳 谆謰 局 埴更熤 骑鼌 喼罡 埴持-埴持 熤株 嬯弥 泣株 曋譄种 祁 综 葜更粗 埴 粗诸弥粗 喼 葜抵, 仓痹 庄謶只 葜囋, 埇指 坳 曋株 恢株葜 仓顨挈 沏鼖 V 局 喼埴更 営更 持 抵泣 埴更 更脐 骑鼌 抵泣 弥指 撝邥蛛 埫舟犏 営更 骑鼌 泣粗 仓浲 ゃ 祁 综 嬯弥 撝邥蛛 泣株 更泣 骑鼌 泣粗 喼埴株 抵泣钟 更 仓熤值种 喼罡 泣粗指 埴株卓挚 抵泣 祁 综 嬯弥 泣 泣株 撝肿泣媴 仓综粗熤 弥 粗 喼埴株.....(镜志脂种)

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 粗泣株抵, 嬠......(镜志脂种)

林 埊置殖种谉 : 曋株恐 曋, り苤, We cannot convert it into a debate. り苤, 泣謭弥 粗 熤弋 懼訖挈.....(镜志脂种)

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 局泣钟 懼謾 粗 弥仓 灼ゆ 粗指挈 曋謰......(镜志脂种)

林 埊置殖种谉 : り苤, 抵泣 仓譄 灼ゃ-粗忝只执种 埴 泣 祁, 喼 尩种 仓指-仓指 抵泣 仓譄 垰熤 骑鼌 抵泣 弥局只 抵泣 泣 祁鼌......(镜志脂种) 嬯弥 仓譄 泣 祁鼌 尩种 囋 讻株欬 恐愫 埴更 撝制鼰株 骑?....(镜志脂种) Let him finish. ...(Interruptions)... He is giving an exhaustive answer.

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 粗旮 嬠 旣株欬 弥 弥泗种局 祁 嚸执蛛厾 曋株 恢株埴恢謬暃 淈株淈 局只种 峡 祁 局泣 粗泣熅织宙拗 嚸 弥粗抵 泣株 葜抵 祁鼌 喼 曋株 弥指挈 悉挈恐 埴, 弥指挈 更謺抵 埴 局拗援 综种, 弥指 坫鷶 综种 局泣 喼 更弥蛛 持 仓熤值种 V謪 喼埴 曋株 镜志置V謰 泣株 更泣 骑 局泣 啹之株 喼 粗 泣粗 埫置株 弥泣粗熤 骑, 曋株 粗 泣粗弥 曋湖更熤 泣株葜 局泣 泣粗 埴更 埴株 熤畹种更 骑鼌 恢曜埴 抵泣 曋株 淈株淈 粗 恢株葜 骑 嚸 弥粗抵, 埉舟 啹之株 懼更 局肿弥 曋之种 祁 喼罡 局泣钟 仓顨挈-仓顨挈 持 埉 更 喼畚洲 泣株 更泣 祁鼌

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 : 埫舟 镜志置V 埴更 る株

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 埉舟 懼更 沏狱撝之种, 埉舟 镜志置V 埴更 喼罡 弥郑 粗 埉舟 泣祝值种更 り种 熤肿埴 埉舟 曋株 拙只株曋 埴粗隀 祁 局泣钟 局 弥愀踔熤 更泣 弥垭鷧 啿 熤株 抵泣 媽弥株曋 泣株 葜 骑鼌 嚸执蛛 粗丬抵 弥局只 抵泣 祁 综 埉舟犏 曋呔之 埴 弥愀种 泣株, 抵泣 仓阕抵证 仓譄 祁鼌

SHRI SHIVRAJ VISHWANATH PATIL: I will explain it. ...(Interruptions)...

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 嚸执蛛 粗旮 抵泣 喼葜掀 祁 综 曋株 恢株葜 更 り 更脐 骑, 悉衷 埴更 更脐 骑, 恢葜譄种更......(镜志脂种)

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 : 埉舟 仓株谆謰  综 抵泣 粗熤 埴更株

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 埉 更 恢葜譄种更 泣V葜株恢 憋种, 嗇指 埴株囋 曋慊宙弥 曋 更泣 祁, り苤 嬯弥 株 懼欬謰 泣株 葜囋 骑鼌......(镜志脂种)

SHRI JANARDHANA POOJARY: Sir, we should also be allowed to speak.

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 嬠 旣株欬 弥 仓譄 埴株 恢贳 埴恢 驻 持更 仓泣弥 埴更謬詤.....(镜志脂种) 粗 局泣 埴泣 更泣 奇狱, 喼 更 埴株囋 喼更株-蠠抵指戬 泣 埴更 更泣 奇狱厾 曋株 弥粗玫种 祁 埫执蛛 持指鼰 弥更埴指 喼 镁值钟 埫舟犏 献熤 負肿熤熤 骑鼌 泣粗 嚐之种 泣 埴泣 撝制鼰株 骑 综 局泣钟 讜置 羡更 埴 更, 悉衷 曋株 泣株 更泣 祁 尩种 局泣钟 埴 弥更埴指 抵 泣粗 嚐之株 喢制抵 泣株 葜 祁 综 弥撝 粗 喼曋 泣粗 埉舟 弥愀种 泣 埴更  更脐 骑 喼罡 埴株囋 仓浲 持指 弥榆抵 粗 恢株葜 更 泣 り 更泣 骑, 埴株囋 局泣钟 更 钟撝 弥诸 恢株葜 曋 更脐 骑, 埴株囋 株 弥诸 恢株葜 曋 更脐 骑, 局 啹之种 现隀挈脵 埴更 更脐 骑 喼罡 抵泣 持 埴泣 更脐 骑, 弥に种局 坳 弥郑 粗 埴泣 更泣 奇狱 综 局泣钟 弥持 局葜猪 坳, 粗猪 坳 恢株葜 骑 局泣钟 喼罡 埫执蛛 埴粗 弥 埴粗 嚐之诌 熤株 镜志置V 埴更謬, 埉舟 更踔 熤株 泣株 弥坳鷧

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 : 粗 喼埴株 仓熤恢譄种 奇狱厾 林叽之, 粗 抵泣 仓株恢 撝制嬗种 综 抵泣 曋株 粗执只种 祁 喼 仓浲 弥訒诌葜 弥 垰抵 祁 喼罡 讜置 酌蠙 粗 垰抵 祁 埫 酌蠙 粗暧 粗 埫舟 曋局植 り株 埴 埴株卓挚 埴更 更泣 奇狱厾 埫 更 综诌 羡更 弥 持 更謺舟抵 赣 泣 撝溚种 撝肿泣媴 粗 抵泣 仓熤之种 撝制嬗种 综 局泣钟 更 恢株葜 曋粗 沏鼖 骑, 局 局肿弥 曋之种 撝制鼰株 骑鼌 埉舟 局肿弥 恢 曋之株 埴 泣粗 娓 囉熤曋执 埴更 る株厾 粗葜更 粗 抵泣 持 埫舟犏 弥郑-弥郑 埴奇狱葜 综 淈株淈 粗 坫鷶 沏鼏, ゆ指 曋葜泣 更 坫鷶 沏鼏 喼罡 嗇指 嚸舟犏 谆謰 悉衷 撝恢熤 更脐 熤株 恢烛 嬘淈 喼浽 埴 酌謸帚嬁之 粗 粗 泣株 局只诌 祁 抵 熤埴恢弑 泣株 局只诌 祁, 嚸舟 持 种 粗暧 更苤雲 粗 喼埴株 抵泣钟 喼谰种弥 り鼰种 奇狱 综 曋株 恢株葜 曋粗 沏鼖 骑 埉舟 局肿弥 沏狱撝之株 埴 埴执 弥更埴指 埴 熤更柄 弥 泣粗 曋湖更 埴更局 る株厾 粗葜更 粗 喼弥 抵泣钟 更 抵泣 持 拙之譄诌 埴更 撝制嬗种 综 抵泣 悉衷 埴更坳 抵泣 状謾株 局只诌 仓譄 泣哂 祁, 嚸舟 喼 综种, 局泣 喼埴株 喿埴指 持 祁 喼罡 啿 嚸舟犏 仓证 嚸舟 更株埴 埴 持 埴执 埴咦曋媴 啿 嗇指 埴泣 更 持 嬯弥 撝邥 泣株熤 祁 熤株 埫舟犏 夲更 悉衷 埴更 弥 坫鷶 泣 泣株熤, 垱忘呙种 粗 沏鼏.....(镜志脂种)

林 拙之值 埴讬种更 : 更 熤株 弥粗织熤 埴更 驻种 葜抵謪

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 : 局 恢株葜 更 坳 谆謰 泣 恢謰 葜 V 局泣钟 更

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 曋株 更 坳 谆謰 喼 V, 局 局泣钟 弥 嚸肿恢 局肿弥 泣 曋 謰 综 埉舟 弥愀种 埴 喜钟 泣 V謪 局 埫诌 坳 埴指 弥 过坳 沏鼖 V陞 仓舟 局泣钟 更 熤株 弥粗织熤 泣株 葜抵謪

林 卓志指曋 局0 肿欬恢 :牋 局泣 粗 埴更局 ゆ狱葜謪 局泣 埴泣 更脐 V 综 泣粗 抵泣钟 更泣 撝制朦葜, 埴粗隀 粗 曋之种 撝制朦葜 喼罡 泣祝值种更 恢戤种 撝制朦葜 嬠犏-47, 局 埴泣 更脐 骑 综鸂 喼 嚐之株 嬠犏-47 欔曜更脵 弥 曋粗 综鷭 骑 熤株 泣粗埴株 仓钟讬鼖厾 泣粗 局泣 り株 坳 谆謰 熤畹种更 骑鼌 粗葜更 埫舟犏 弥郑-弥郑 曋仓 泣粗 り株 坳 谆謰 熤畹种更 骑, 弥更埴指 り株 坳 谆謰 熤畹种更 祁, 坳 弥更埴指 泣, 局泣钟 埴 弥更埴指 泣 埴更 更泣 祁鼌牋牋牋牋牋牋 (4c 更 畚挚炙:)

TMV-GS/5.55/4C

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 (畚种葜熤) : 泣粗 り株 坳 谆謰 熤畹种更 骑, 粗泗株 坫鷶 弥创种桩譄 弥玫种  曋湖更 埴泣 喼罡 埉舟 仓譄 粗 仓沏鼰 曋株更 祁 综 り 更脐 骑, 熤株 综舟 り 更脐 骑, 嚸舟 持 种 更总謰葜..

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 埉 泣祝值种更蛛 埴 综诌 持 熤更泣 弥 ゃ值种贻 泣 泣株

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 : 泣钟

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 埉舟 埊值种贻 泣粗指挈 泣 り 坳 拙趾  泣株, 嚸舟 弥志脂种 更苤 曋之诌 撝肿泣, 嚸舟 泣粗 粗之譄株 骑, 恢曜埴 曋株 恢株葜 局泣钟 嚸 弥粗抵 骑, 埉执蛛 弥 埴株囋 嗇指 嬯弥 祁 综 讜置 更 ゃ值种贻 埴更 埴 弥映种局 祁, 熤株 埫舟 弥更埴指 埴株 り之种 撝肿泣媴

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 : 埫诌 埴 曋钟撝 埴更 更脐 骑鼌

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 恢曜埴 曋株 局泣钟 喢帚更柞譄 浲挈 沏鼖 骑, 埉舟 弥愀种 泣株 撝肿泣媴

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 : 泣钟, 埉舟 粗 囉熤曋执 埴更局 ゆ狱葜謪 ゆ指 熤更柄 埴泣 持 懼欬 懼欬 祁, 熤株 泣粗 埫舟 烛谆肿欬埴恢 泣 恢 更脐 骑..

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 泣粗 持 泣 恢 更脐 骑鼌

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 : 抵泣 埴泣 持 泣株, 嗇指 抵.. 粗 泣株 抵 垱忘呙种 粗 泣株 抵 旣⒅呙州譁忘 粗 泣株, 泣粗指 埫置株 埴株囋 烛谆肿欬埴恢 葜戤 埴更 埴 埀挈康 泣 祁鼌 埴恢 旣⒅呙州譁忘 粗 粗謬 不种脵 粗 恢株葜 粗指挈 葜抵, 埫舟 泣粗 垰 更脐 骑, 恢曜埴 烛谆肿欬埴恢 泣 垰 更脐 骑鼌 局泣 昕之只 嚳抵 祁, 弥陮抵阕更欬 埴 嚳抵 祁鼌 ..(镜志脂种)..

淈0 粗愀诌 粗株泣更 曋株恐 : 局泣 熤株 曋泣钟 埴泣 持 祁, 埫执蛛 泣粗 弥更埴指 埴 弥郑 る株 弥指挈 坳 弥指挈 堓窒局证 埴株 弥粗织熤 埴更 坳 谆謰 泣粗指 謾 埴 熤更柄 弥 弥更埴指 埴株 弥泣抵株葜 泣株葜謪

林 卓志指曋 局. 肿欬恢 : 喼 埴泣 更脐 骑, 涥柄隀诌

(弥粗织熤)


STATEMENT RE. STATUS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF

RECOMMENDATIONS CONTAINED IN 2ND AND 10TH

REPORTS OF DEPARTMENT-RELATED PARLIAMENTARY

STANDING COMMITTEE ON RURAL DEVELOPMENT.

 

葜现粗咿 拙舟弥 粗印诌 (林 更懼憔钟恐 厦种 孛制) : 粗泣株抵, 粗 拙殖种葜 弥硬钟赚譄 葜现粗咿 拙舟弥 弥硬钟 弥用证抵 茫种抵 弥状肿熤 坳 ゆ指挈 喼罡 弥局 献熤局辘种暧 粗 営熤倬致欬 酌直赘种 坳 埴值种援局抵 埴 酌V谉 坳 弥硬钟 粗霠 局専志抵 弥 坳 欬恢 更 更苤熤 奇狱厾牋 (弥粗织熤)

MATTER RAISED WITH PERMISSION OF CHAIR

RE. DEATHS OF LABOURS FROM ANDHRA PRADESH

IN A FIRE ACCIDENT IN KUWAIT

 

SHRI C. RAMACHANDRAIAH (ANDHRA PRADESH): Sir, I wish to draw the attention of the Government to a fire accident which took place at Kaitain in Kuwait. As per the Press reports, 11 persons died and all of them are from my native place, from Cuddapah District of Andhra Pradesh. They went there for some labour work. They are the sole breadwinners of their families. Unfortunately, they died in a fire accident. Till now their mortal remains have not been brought to their places and their relatives are crying like anything. I request the Government to immediately initiate some measures so that their bodies could be brought and handed over to their relatives. Sufficient compensation should also be paid to their families. That should be ensured by the Government. I draw the attention of the Government to this incident.

牋牋牋 Sir, I wrote a letter to the hon. Minister of External Affairs on 15th May.牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋牋 (Ends)

弥用证抵 埴值衷 粗印种恢抵 粗 更謺抵 粗印诌 (林 弥愀挈恐 撝诸更) : 弥创种桩譄 埊置殖种谉 粗泣株抵, 喼更拗叩 弥玫  讜置 屈抵 拙证更埴 懼欬 埴 埢恢贶 综种 祁, 局泣 桩肿繐譄 湖 弥 泣粗 弥仓 坳 谆謰 仓浲 負譄之诌抵 祁 喼罡 嚸 拙致值 粗 弥硬钟赚譄 粗印诌 曋 弥 仓譄 埴更坳, 曋株 持 弥粗阕撝熤 埊种抵 垰抵 曋 弥垭株, 局泣 泣粗 垰 埴 娓 埴株卓挚 埴鸽株厾牋 (弥粗织熤)


 

SPECIAL MENTIONS

NEED FOR SAVING OUR CITIES

SHRI VIJAY J. DARDA (MAHARASHTRA): Sir, thank you very much for allowing me to make a Special Mention on the need for saving our cities.

牋牋牋 Sir, the recent World Bank study has revealed that poor quality of life in Indian cities causes about 30,000 premature deaths, 17 million hospital admissions are due to respiratory problems and three cities, namely, Delhi, Mumbai and Kolkata, account for 44 per cent of these deaths. These unhealthy conditions cause an annual loss of 30.5 million "disability adjusted life years" which is equivalent to Rs.36,000 crores. This calls for appreciating this gigantic task and urgently enforcing strict urban discipline, making implementation machinery effective and locating new financial, technical and managerial resources.

牋牋牋 The sewerage system covers 35 per cent of the population of Class IV cities and 75 per cent of Class I cities. About 34 per cent of the people in urban areas do not have any arrangement for drainage of rainwater and about 60 per cent of municipal bodies collect less than 40 per cent of the solid waste generated daily. At least 28 per cent of the urban waste is allowed to decompose and putrefy, thereby choking drains and thus becoming breeding grounds for pests, flies, mosquitoes and cockroaches.

牋牋牋 Mumbai floods in July, 2005 and September, 2005 are a living example of the worst scenario of ineptitude of municipal authorities and reckless constructions. An enlightened vision, strong political will and positive direction can only save our cities from total collapse. A comprehensive land policy needs to be formulated treating land as a source for creating socially and environmentally harmonious communities; and creating a dedicated cadre of urban administrations capable of effectively facing growing challenges. Thank you.牋牋牋牋牋牋 (Ends)

(Followed by 4D/VK)

PREVIOUS HOUR
MAIN
NEXT HOUR